Categories
The European

The European: I just don’t want one

AUSmotive.com - The European
HSV VT Clubsport

When I arrived in Australia, I saw a land of milk and honey. A land full of sun-kissed blondes and brunettes, sand and sun. I had landed in Bondi in the middle of December after a trip to Thailand which deviated as far from the conscientious traveller as you can imagine. Eat Thai food? You’re kidding. We watched James Bond in Siam Square after having eaten at Hungry Jacks and at McDonalds and ingratiated ourselves with every local within 500m of the Kho Sahn Road and no further for fear of missing out on happy hour.

Australia looked to be just more of the same boozing and sitting on the beach and I loved it the moment I saw it. My mate Chris, as big an automotive tragic as me, was immediately taken by the cars here. We would cross four lanes of traffic to see what would now qualify merely as “a shitbox”. But, to us at the time, it was like landing on another planet and discovering squirrels with two heads. Every so often a bogan would roll past in a VN Commodore with enough modifications to make Max Rockatansky’s Interceptor look like an OAP special and, having been raised on one litre French hatchbacks, we would stop and drool. Yeah, I know.

It was about the time that Holden had the Commodore VT, which we knew from back home as the Vauxhall Omega, Chris’ dad having had one when he momentarily lost touch with his Volvoness. Omegas were really quite a fashion forward design at the time, so to see the same thing with a slight Antipodean bent was of real interest. Sensing our moment as a sort of latter day automotive Joseph Banks’, we mentally began noting the various differences, which started with four more cylinders and double the capacity of the most popular Omegas back home. The interior didn’t have quite the same attention to detail as the Omega but the first time we saw a red Clubsport in Canberra the effect was immediate—this M5 eating beast had everything two Poms could ever want and I promised myself that one day I would have myself one. A few weeks later I was walking back to our flat and saw one parked up so edged closer for a proper perv.

Imagine going in for a kiss with Sarah Murdoch and just as her chest begins to press against yours, you see… the mole. The hairy, how-did-I-miss-it mole.

In this case of vehicular spoil I’m talking about is the body panel shut line between the rear door and the rear wing, or more accurately the rear wheel arch itself. This is a line that arches around the rear wheel to a ten o’clock position then tucks itself into the underside of the door frame, leaving the most unresolved piece of industrial design I have ever seen.

It’s really that bad and yes I’m really being that much of a pedant. It’s as though the engineer and designer forgot to agree who was going to sort this bit out and then—bam—the project had been signed off and they were already pressing body panels by the thousand at Elizabeth and the cars were sitting in showrooms by the hundreds.

So does it matter? To the thousands of real buyers and fleet managers not one bit of course, but to car tragics like me it matters a lot. No matter how good that car was—and plenty of European mags raved about its prowess, I could never have bought it.

And I have plenty of others in my bag of shame, so step forward Lexus, who might well have executed the tightest laser cut shut lines in the industry and the most highly engineered vehicles yet to come out of any factory but they can’t make a classy gear lever surround to save their life. This part simply needs to state PRND32 and if you drive a European executive car you’ll know what I mean, because the graphics Lexus use for this are nothing short of comically putrid compared to the simple white graphics of a Mercedes.

Lexus did a fantastic job of ripping off (or in polite circles “being inspired by”) certain European marques, but when it came to their interior typeface they seemed to have gone for Eighties Sony Walkman. Consequently I never got to own an IS200, which is a pity because as far as interesting cars go I think I would have liked to.

People sometimes ask why I don’t like certain cars and probably think I’m being unnecessarily evasive when I stare at my feet and mumble something about “design integrity” but you know what? It’s really hard trying to articulate how furious the boot lock on the Mk1 Focus makes me and not to look like I should be put away into a home for lunatics.

So, you’re a car tragic, too, right? What details get you mad and did any ever stop you buying a car?

11 replies on “The European: I just don’t want one”

On the Vauxhall/Opel Astra which has just been replaced, the brakes are like an on-/off-switch and if you try to cancel the indicator by hand it will just start to indicate in the other direction. Within minutes of first getting into this car I hated it. No car got me angry that fast!

For me it’s the older model Mazda3 sedans. There is an ugly keyhole for the boot smack bang in the middle of the boot, and it isn’t even integrated into the boot at all. It was enough for me to choose the hatch over the sedan.

The most important aspect of automotive design in my eyes, the place that separates art from are-you-crazy, is the integration of the falling C-pillar into the rear shoulder. It needs to be absolutely flawless. The roofline and the beltline, if viewed in profile or otherwise, cause the eye to naturally scan the surfaces to where the two eventually meet. It is especially true for coupe or coupe-like styling. It is like a contradicting mathematics problem: two parallels that intersect. Of course, you’re bound to have a look. The beauty in a well-designed car lies entirely in the smooth blend of C-pillar meeting the rear shoulder, to my eyes. Subtle details can enhance this aesthetic; the Hoffmeister kink in BMWs is the first example that comes to mind. To view Hoffmeister’s masterpiece on an E39 5 Series from the rear three-quarters is an experience not unlike seeing a Van Gogh at the Getty. I’ve done both, and I might prefer the German’s ghost stroke over the one the Dutchman’s brush made. The purity of line that lies therein, the harmony that is created by the gentle treatment of the sheetmetal surface, the tension that is suggested and the stress that is contained, all speak of sublime treasures that are the greatest of joys to discover. In a well-designed treatment, there is solemn and sensual balance. It is an imaginative expression of the material that all automobiles are made of; its limitations, its enhanced room for creation and experimentation are expressed here. The shoulder and C-pillar treatment possesses a fluid and refined quality, if done well. If not, however, and if it lacks finesse and if it is raw and coarse and appears flat, it causes a distancing reaction that will never be reversed. The C-pillar rising out of the flat world around around it appears as out of place as an automatic gearbox in a sports car. Sculptural elements need to softly and gently emerge to become the C-pillar in a manner that the transition is almost seamless. It should exude dynamism and be natural, like it shouldn’t be any other way. The majesty of this characteristic detail is grace. It should not be a directionless form. If done well, the C-pillar and rear shoulder treatment creates a longing desire to maintain this discovery of the truth in beauty, the provocation of thought through design and to continually search out harmony in the lines that surround the cars in our lives. If the eye comes across a bad example of this execution, the sadness felt while cringing at its very existence is indescribable.

The dopey shape of the mkV GTI headlights! I almost don’t notice it now they’ve been out for 5 years, but that one detail ruined the whole car for me.

I have a real dislike for being able to see mufflers from behind cars/under rear valances. There’s plenty of examples to show how the muffler can be hidden away successfully.

So, the unfinished looking Alfa 147 with its muffler hanging out is a real pet hate of mine. It’s made even worse by the fact the whole rear valance detail gives the car an SUV like profile, in that the valance sits way too high.

Horrible.

I held off on buying a Pirelli GTI last year because of those god awful seats. Plus contrast stitching is generally nice but that wee yellow didn’t really work.

I am picking up a Golf R soon so it’s been a massive win. I get a faster and better looking car for around the same price as the older and uglier Pirelli! Happy days.

Okay, I haven’t built up too much loathing for it yet but if you happen to own a Golf MK6…check out the black interior trim on the B pillar.

http://www.ausmotive.com/images/Golf-VI-90TSI-05s.jpg

you can see that a portion of it is recessed, the bottom of which flows nicely into the door arm rest. Now check out the upper part of that recess which ends up wondering where to go because it doesn’t match the upper door trims. Why? Because VW cost cut and carried over this part from the Mk5, where it worked, to the Mk6 where it doesn’t.

If you drive a Bangle BMW you probably have no idea what i’m on about.

[Ed: The European gets a wrap over the knuckles for not linking to AUSmotive] 😛

toyota interiors boil my blood, aurion especially
the pale blue stereo panel looks like something transplanted from a cheap TEAC stereo.

Comments are closed.